Share this article
LEADERSHIP: New Australian CEOs are already being paid around 33 per cent less than their predecessors as boards listen to the concerns of shareholders, employees and the community, says Debra Eckersley, executive remuneration partner at PwC. But some would argue the change in CEO pay rates is happening too slowly.
Research shows perceptions about executive pay are hampering trust in business to play a significant role in tackling income equality. And the old argument that companies create wealth and societies distribute it is increasingly seen as a furphy in the Australian community, and around the world.
“Companies are viewed as social entities in their own right,” Eckersley says. “And both the reality and perception of the fairness of executive pay is an issue that has to be dealt with, especially as wage growth is low and growing inequality is the hot topic in societal debates and now spans the political divide.”
PwC research shows that about 30 per cent of people feel companies are not delivering on the principles of fairness they espouse. Young people, in particular, are more cynical about trusting the market to produce morally appropriate outcomes and want stronger protection for the less well off. “These views are only likely to strengthen as the impact of job losses through technological and other disruption takes hold,” she says.
Photograph by Nic Walker
The US and UK governments are already taking action by announcing requirements for large companies to disclose the ratio of their CEO pay compared to their average (UK) or median (US) worker pay.
“You can’t put your head in the sand and ignore the questions from media, shareholders and the community, who are often your customers, asking do you really think that your CEO is worth 100 times what your average worker gets? And what are you as a company doing to help the average worker who hasn’t had a pay rise for several years and is anxious about job security?”
Australian boards have to address community concerns with CEO pay – because without a change in approach, government will step in with more regulation, Eckersley says.
“My prediction is that the direction to disclose CEO pay ratios is coming. If Australian boards don’t focus more on income equality and fairness, government is ready and waiting to regulate.”
And CEO pay ratios can be misleading. For CEOs at a high paying company (for example, an investment bank), the disclosed pay ratio may look fine as all employees are well paid. However, in some companies (such as fast food or retail), where the average wage is lower, the CEO pay ratio is likely to be higher.
Suggesting the pay ratios at these two companies should be similar would be wrong but confusion will reign if companies don’t get on the front foot. Eckersley says companies
You can’t put your head in the sand and ignore the questions from media, shareholders and the community, who are asking do you really think your CEO is worth 100 times what your average worker gets?
need to consider and better articulate what they think fair means from an employee, customer and shareholder perspective. Designing a suitable remuneration structure is only part of the challenge.
“A good stakeholder engagement and communications strategy is almost as important as the actual remuneration structure,” she says.
“Ironically, it’s often organisations trying to cater for every shareholder demand that have remuneration structures difficult for both shareholders and executives to understand – and pervasively can drive up executive pay through all the complexity.”
On the board agenda:
The Press is a publication by PwC Australia, aimed at sharing expertise, capturing insights and working together to solve important problems.
Why does someone trust a stranger over a CEO? Will companies even have a CEO? World-renowned trust expert Rachel Botsman explains how trust is won and lost in a digital age.
With the world at the brink of unprecedented change, Julie Bishop explains the challenges ahead and why she’s optimistic about Australia’s prospects.
As work changes and part-time jobs dry up, many companies will be taking on young people who have never worked.
This article first appeared in Edition 4 of The Press
By Charlie Carter Senior Reporter, The Press, PwC Australia
© 2017 - 2018 PwC. All rights reserved. PwC refers to the PwC network and/or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.